Catholic ban on contraception

The development of the Birth Control Pill:

The man most prominently associated with the development and introduction of the pill, John Rock, was an Irish Catholic doctor from Boston. Dr. Rock didn’t set out to make waves with the Vatican; in fact, he was sure that his invention would gain approval from the Vatican and finally allow Catholics to practice safe and effective family planning.

The Vatican reconsidered their ban on all artificial contraception:

Soon after the introduction of the pill (in 1963) Pope John XXIII convened a panel in order to decide whether contraception should remain a sin or not. The papal commission on birth control included married Catholic women, and the commission voted overwhelmingly to recommend that the church rescind its ban on contraception.

The Pope, however, decided to reject the commission’s recommendation & instead appointed a second commission, made up of only 15 bishops (all men).  This second commission also voted overwhelmingly to recommend that the church rescind its ban on contraception.

The results of the votes of these two commissions were leaked. It was therefore a significant shock to Catholics Pope Paul VI decided to proclaim the teaching on contraception unchanged and unchangeable (he did this in the release of the Humanae Vitae in 1968).

Did Catholic women obey the Pope’s ban on contraception?

A survey just one year later, in 1989, found that 44% of Catholic women (who were regular churchgoers) were currently using artificial contraception. In 1974, 83% of Catholics said they disagreed with the Pope’s stance on birth control. By 1999, nearly 80 percent of Catholics believed that a person could be a good Catholic without obeying the church hierarchy’s teaching on birth control. A 2005 nationwide poll by Harris Interactive showed that 90% of Catholics supported the use of birth control.

The Center of Disease Control and Prevention 2002 National Survey of Family Growth revealed that 97% of American Catholic women over age 18 have used a banned form of contraception, which is the same percentage as the general population.

HIV/AIDS prevention & the Catholic ban on contraception:

The Catholic ban on contraception has led to abortion, death and disability (eg. fistulas) for women in impoverished Catholic countries denied the ability to limit pregnancies. The Catholic hierarchy has attempted to block access to emergency contraception for women, particularly in Latin America, where it has influence at the highest levels of government.

The Catholic ban on contraception may have also influenced the spread of AIDS. Despite scientific evidence that condoms are a critical piece of AIDS-prevention efforts, the Vatican has refused to relax the ban on contraceptives. The Vatican has used its status at the UN to impose its anti-contraception policies, frustrating the development of comprehensive global family planning and anti-AIDS programs. There has been a growing recognition that abstinence is unrealistic as a primary AIDS strategy in Africa, a continent where there are significant power discrepancies between men and women and many wives are powerless to refuse sex with their husbands, even if they suspect they have been unfaithful.

Read more on the Catholic ban on artificial contraception and it’s consequences here and here.

About these ads
This entry was posted in Contraception, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s